See Description for easier update.

There's also the issue of the titles... Not sure if I missed discussion about this. But a while ago, people in the nightcafe facebook group were talking about voting in daily challenges, and a surprising number of people said that if an image is great, but the title doesn't make sense, or there is no title, or says "untitled," that they downvote it. I tried to get someone to explain to me why the title or lack thereof held so much importance, seemed like more than the image, even. But nobody gave me an answer that I found meaningful, if at all. I can't recall. But I am terrible at titling art, so I was rather disappointed and confused. I used to be quite inclined to forego the title if I didn't think I had a good one. Now I mostly put something there, even if it's lame. Meh.

This is all very subjective, I would add something about technical execution and details, not just creativity. In my opinion, the image in 4 is a little bit kitschy and I'd swap 3 and 4. I might even vote the image in 3 better than the 5. The user @Sxwers had a guide on his profile where 5 is you'd hang it in your living room, and 4 you'd print it out or save it.

Following

Great!

Excellent Idea my friend. I think in Images. This is good for me!

🖤

This is interesting. I wonder how many people use this in voting. Perhaps I'm not creative enough as my daily challenges don't do so well

Fully agree with this example! Exceptionally, when completely off theme but very creative, I put a 2

That’s how I vote on daily and community challenges. 1 and 2 also if it’s an image of a person, they are the main focus of the image, get they have extra or deformed limbs.

Sigh if only lol